LIARS! Sources Say Girl’s Family Lies To Raise Money After Avoidable Dog Attack

By Sloane Quealy-Miner

Square Dog Photography—Getty Images/Flickr Select

Square Dog Photography—Getty Images/Flickr Select

Despicable family lies to public to line their pockets with money and cash. The family should be ashamed of themselves for so many reasons. Unbelievably they have managed to make a horrifying situation for the little girl Victoria Wilcher even worse. Poor Victoria was attacked by her grandfather’s three pit bull dogs when visiting him resulting in life changing injurues. Questions have been raised as to how the dogs were treated as well as if he was breeding them which would have everything to do with why the dogs attacked.

The media continually fails to acknowledge the relevance of stressful or inhumane situations that humans often force dogs to endure. At National Canine Research Council they urge people to consider what the world looks like from their dog’s point of view.

“There are at least two parties involved in a dog bite; a dog and one or more humans. Dog behavior cannot be understood or analyzed apart from humans, or the situations in which humans have placed dogs.”

Everyone is so quick to blame the dogs but what about the grandfather. Had he been a responsible grandfather and pet owner this NEVER would have happened. This was an easily avoidable tragedy. Nevertheless this has caused a flurry of articles to be published with much misinformation about pit bull type dogs.

One article in Time titled “The Problem With Pitbulls” even quoted Colleen Lynn. Colleen Lynn who runs DOGSBITE.ORG is not an expert in the field of canine behavior. She is nothing more than a woman with a grudge. Colleen was the victim of a dog bite in 2007. Because of this incident that involved one individual dog she has decided to enact revenge on ALL pit bull type dogs.

Colleen Lynn blatantly lies on her website when she claims that pit bulls lead dog bite fatalities. She gathers all of her information from media reports, no questions asked. Clearly she doesn’t ask questions because most of what is reported in the media surrounding pit bulls and “attacks” is incorrect and has been repeatedly proven to be untrue.

Many question the truthfulness of Colleen’s account of what happened to her in June of 2007. Her story has changed multiple times. Pit Bulletin Legal News thoroughly investigated the incident and published these never before seen documents. It is clear to myself and many others “that Ms. Lynn never published the Seattle Animal Control records regarding the investigation because the story she is now telling bears very little resemblance to what actually happened, and are in total conflict with the only other witness involved: the dogwalker.”

While Colleen’s blatant disregard for the truth on her website is not a surprise and not unexpected, it is important for all of us to have the correct information easily available. Thankfully there is the National Canine Research Council whose dedicated staff comb through the details of every dog bite related fatality.

I encourage everyone to spend time carefully reading the invaluable information on NCR’s website including the 2010 Dog Bite Fatalities NCR and 2011 Preliminary Dog Bite Fatalities Report

The National Canine Research Council “re-interviews sources the media has reached, and located others they have not, among whom may be police investigators, animal control officers, coroners, veterinarians, health department officials, dog owners, and eye witnesses. They have obtained incident reports, bite reports, human and animal autopsy reports, summaries of judicial proceedings, and crime scene data and photographs when available.

Access the National Canine Research Dog Bite Statistics HERE NCRC’s informative section on ineffective laws including breed specific legislation HERE FAQ’s regarding dog bites HERE and Breed Specific FAQ’s HERE

Dog bite-related fatalities are exceedingly rare. In 2010, 33 fatalities occurred within a population of more than 308 million and a canine population estimated at over 78 million. NCRC is currently investigating 31 incidents in a dog population of over 78 million that occurred during 2011 thay may qualify as dog bite related fatalities. A final tally is subject to change as a result of NCRC’s thorough investigations.

Stories about pit bull attacks are tragic, but isolated incidents. Those stories are blasted all over the news, but it’s stories like the ones below that people never hear about. These are the stories of pit bull heroes – the dogs who selflessly defend their families from heinous crimes, save other animals from certain death, and pull their human guardians to safety in times of danger. Stories about pit bull bravery and heroism are by themselves powerful arguments against breed specific legislation. PIT BULL HERO STORIES

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to LIARS! Sources Say Girl’s Family Lies To Raise Money After Avoidable Dog Attack

  1. Terry says:

    Sloane, Maybe it’s time to start a STOPDOGBITES.COM web site, like activists started the STOPHUMANEWATCH.ORG.
    HUMANEWATCH.ORG was designed by big business to ruin the Humane Society of the US. Berman perpetuates lies about them, one of which is that they don’t donate to shelters, which is not their mission!
    We would donate $50 to start this site which would at least buy a domain name. Sounds like you have already enough material!!
    Thanks for your efforts on behalf of pit bulls :o) terry and scott, pittsfield (yes!) massachusetts

  2. Sue Marston says:

    I’ve been in rescue, antivivisection,and advocacy for animals for many years. I love all dogs, but always been partial to pit bulls, and one of those should be on the heroes list, as he saved me from an assault 4 1/2 years ago, and handled the aggressor without biting. I have to protect him from other dogs (including a min pin I rescued) because he will not bite them no matter what they do to him. As for HSUS though, whatever their mission is, they have committed many flagrant crimes against animals, including advocating for Michael Vick !!! While I would recommend the site that true animal hero Nathan O. WInograd has on HSUS, I must include that when I first started trying to expose the behind-the-scenes torture of K9’s by the police/sheriffs/military, HSUS would not help. Years later, still trying to expose this horrible nightmare, I called in to a radio show featuring Stephanie Shain of HSUS to ask her why HSUS would not help the K9’s. She said to email her about it. I did, and kept being put off, again and again and again. MY website on that subject is

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s